Category: Uncategorized

Leveraging Fear to Limit Rights: The Anti-Abortion Movement’s Use of Reproductive Coercion as a Justification for Limiting Access to Abortion Care

On September 30, 2026, the state of Louisiana—joined by Arkansas and Alabama—filed a lawsuit against the states of New York, Massachusetts, and California, alleging that existing shield law provisions protecting doctors who provide access to medication abortion through telehealth and via mail, are unconstitutional. The complaint claims, among other things, that the ability to access Mifepristone, the FDA approved medication for terminating a pregnancy, via mail results in reproductive coercion in the form of forced abortions. It’s an argument that is appearing in more and more cases across the country; that the best way to protect pregnant people against reproductive coercion is to limit access to mifepristone, now the most common method of abortion and, in states like Louisiana, among the only remaining options. 

Despite its ubiquity, the argument is inescapably wrong. The term ‘reproductive coercion’ was coined in 2010 by Dr. Elizabeth Miller and her colleagues to describe the form of intimate partner violence in which an abuser exerts control over their partner’s reproductive choices. The initial research, which focused on the risks of reproductive coercion used to enforce a pregnancy, not to terminate one, found that reproductive coercion increases the risk of unwanted pregnancy. Subsequent studies have confirmed that the primary risk in situations of abortion coercion remains that a person will be forced to become or remain pregnant, not they will be forced to terminate a pregnancy, and that the claims being advanced by anti-abortion advocates that access to medication abortion will increase reproductive coercion are distorting the facts. Ultimately, while the concept remains underresearched, we know that it is estimated to impact one in four women, that it includes many forms beyond coerced abortion, and that the loss of reproductive rights causes it to skyrocket. 

In fact, as the strategy of seeking to limit abortion access in the name of preventing reproductive coercion has gained prominence, so too has the leveraging of the legal system by abusers to punish their partners for choosing to terminate pregnancies. This commingling of forms of violence—here reproductive coercion and litigation abuse—is a common occurrence in the context of domestic violence, where we know that the restriction of options and reduction of control over one’s choices limits a victim’s ability to escape a dangerous situation. In fact, the intersection of abortion restrictions and domestic violence has consistently gone in the opposite direction as that proposed by conservative thinkers; instead of preventing coercion and its underlying violence, restrictions on access to abortion increase reproductive coercion and the other forms of domestic violence that often accompany it, a fact confirmed by the overwhelming response of domestic violence groups to litigation seeking to limit access to mifepristone. 

The deployment of the narrative that the best way to protect against domestic violence is to restrict access to abortion is cause for concern not just because it will yield exactly the results it purports to prevent, but because it justifies the structural codification of reproductive coercion perpetrated by the state itself. By shrouding the bid for control in the language of protection of women, Louisiana and its partners have joined a long tradition of leveraging domestic violence and violence against women more broadly in the name of expanding state control and limiting public rights. Domestic violence is itself increasingly recognized as a public health crisis, which has been compounded by the loss of access to reproductive care caused by abortion restrictions, even while that loss has created a crisis all its own. In the context of an American public health system increasingly focused on personal responsibility above community support, coupled with the criminalization of pregnancy complications, this strategy of further limiting pregnant people’s options is incredibly dangerous. To do so in the name of protecting those people does little more than add insult to injury.